The main theme of "The Etiquette of Freedom" by Gary Snyder is the deep and natural connection between humans and the wild world. Snyder emphasises that humans are animals too, sharing the same instincts, behaviours, and natural responses as other living creatures. He argues that our minds and bodies are part of nature, and even our language and culture grew out of our animal existence. True freedom, according to Snyder, comes from accepting this wildness within us and living in harmony with nature rather than trying to control or separate from it. He encourages us to live simply, respectfully, and attentively to understand the land, respect other beings, and find joy in ordinary moments. This respectful way of living in nature is what he calls the “etiquette of freedom,” a kind of wisdom that guides us to be both free and responsible as part of the natural world.
Summary
In "The Etiquette of Freedom," Gary Snyder explores the deep connection between human beings and the natural world, emphasising our shared biological and spiritual roots with all living creatures. He begins with a fundamental question: Do we truly believe we are animals? Although this idea is commonly taught, many fail to fully absorb its implications. Snyder argues that acknowledging our animal nature helps us recognise the continuity between ourselves and other forms of life, rather than imagining ourselves as superior or separate.
He reflects on his own upbringing on a farm near a forest, where he learned to see humans and animals as coexisting within the same natural order. He emphasises that our bodies are inherently wild: they react instinctively, breathe and function without our conscious control. These natural responses, such as feeling fear or awe, illustrate the deep-rooted animality within us. Our mind and body, he says, are not separate but integrated, and both are wild. The unconscious, filled with thoughts, images, and dreams, is described as a kind of inner wilderness where even symbolic wild creatures like bobcats roam.
Snyder challenges the idea that language separates humans from animals. While animals may not speak as we do, they communicate in complex ways. Human language, according to Snyder, did not arise from a sudden burst of intelligence, but evolved naturally from our animal existence. It is not something we fully control or understand; rather, it is a wild, spontaneous force that flows through us. Children acquire language effortlessly without being taught grammar, suggesting that language comes from deep within, possibly from the patterns in nature itself, such as rivers, wind, flowers, or birdsong.
He criticises formal language education for taming and narrowing this rich capacity, focusing on “elite” cultural forms and professional standards. Though useful, these do not capture the true power and wildness of language. Similarly, Snyder views social order not as a purely human invention but as a natural phenomenon, existing in the structure of nature itself long before laws or governments.
The core message of the essay lies in what Snyder calls “the etiquette of freedom.” He argues that we can embrace our humanity fully, our intelligence, desires, and emotions, without trying to dominate or escape nature. True freedom comes not from resisting nature, but from accepting our place within it. This means living respectfully, simply, and attentively as equals with all beings, sharing the earth.
He paints a poetic picture of such a life: sitting with a friend over coffee, wiping grease from one’s hands, watching clouds drift by, all grounded in presence, humility, and gratitude. Living freely in the wild requires us to know the land, respect its creatures, and return from our journeys with stories to share.
Importance of the Text
"The Etiquette of Freedom" is important because it helps us understand our true relationship with nature. Gary Snyder reminds us that we are not separate from the natural world: we are part of it. This message is especially meaningful today, when many people live far from nature and forget their connection to the earth and other living beings. The text encourages us to respect the wildness within ourselves and in the world around us. It teaches that real freedom comes from living simply, being aware, and treating all life with care and kindness. By seeing ourselves as equal members of the natural community, we can live more peacefully and responsibly. This essay also challenges modern views that value control, power, or success over harmony with nature. Thus, it offers deep wisdom about how to live well and stay connected to the earth.
Understanding
1. How does Snyder establish the vocabulary for a discussion of "practising" the wild?
Snyder uses words and ideas from nature, biology, and daily human experience to talk about "practising" the wild. He talks about the human body, instincts, the unconscious mind, and natural behaviours. He connects wildness not just to forests or animals, but also to language, thought, and daily life. By blending natural images with human actions, he builds a clear and strong way to talk about how we can live in harmony with the wild.
2. Do you agree with Snyder that man is an animal? Why?Yes, I agree with Snyder that man is an animal. He shows that humans have the same natural instincts, emotions, and physical reactions as other animals. Our bodies function automatically, like other creatures, and we are part of nature. Accepting this helps us live more simply and respect all life.
3. "Our bodies are wild" (2). How does the writer establish this idea?
Snyder explains that our bodies act on their own, like turning our head when we hear a shout or feeling fear on the edge of a cliff. These are natural, automatic responses that do not need conscious thinking. He says the body and the mind are both wild and work together, showing that our inner lives are just as wild as the natural world.
4. Is language a uniquely human invention? Where is it learnt?Snyder argues that language is not just a human invention. He believes it grew naturally from our life as animals and is connected to nature. Animals also communicate in their own ways. Human language is not fully taught in schools; it is mostly learned at home, in daily life, and from our environment, without needing grammar lessons.
5. What is "social order" (8)? How does the writer argue that social order is found throughout nature?
"Social order" means the ways that living beings live and work together peacefully. Snyder says social order is not just created by humans; it exists naturally in the animal world and even in the patterns of rocks and rivers. He believes that governments and rules are copies of nature’s systems, like balance, flow, and harmony.
6. What lesson do we learn from the wild? Explain in detail.The wild teaches us to live freely but responsibly. Snyder says we should live simply, be aware of our surroundings, respect all living things, and feel equal to them. We should stop trying to be superior or eternal, and instead accept our place in nature. The wild also teaches us to pay attention, be thankful, and enjoy the small moments in life, like wiping our hands or talking with a friend. Practising the wild means knowing the land, respecting creatures, and living with honesty and care.
Rhetoric/Language/Writing
1. How does Snyder bring in the idea of "Deep Ecology," a philosophy holding that responsible citizenship of the world includes mindfulness with regard to humans and nonhumans alike?
Snyder brings in the idea of Deep Ecology by showing that humans are part of the natural world, not separate from it. He says we are animals too, and we share this world with plants, animals, rivers, and stones. He encourages us to respect all living beings and live in balance with them. He believes that being a good citizen of the world means being kind, aware, and responsible towards both humans and nonhumans. This idea matches the philosophy of Deep Ecology.
2. How, Snyder argues, do we get into the depths of the wild unconscious?Snyder says we enter the wild unconscious through dreams, thoughts, images, and feelings that come without being planned. These are the parts of our mind that we don’t fully control. He compares this deep inner world to a wilderness where things like bobcats roam in dreams. The wild unconscious is not something we create; it already exists inside us. We just need to notice and accept it.
3. Write an essay on the relationship between nature and the organic world around us.
The Relationship Between Nature and the Organic World Around Us
Nature and the organic world are deeply connected. Everything that lives, i.e. humans, animals, trees, flowers, rivers, and even the wind, is part of the organic world. Nature is not something outside us; we are part of it. Our bodies are made of the same materials as the Earth. We breathe the same air, drink the same water, and depend on plants and animals for food and life.
Gary Snyder, in The Etiquette of Freedom, reminds us that we are animals, too. This means we share the same natural space with other living beings. Our thoughts, feelings, and language also come from nature. We do not fully control them; they rise from deep inside us, like dreams or instincts. This wild part of us connects us to the world around us.
The relationship between humans and nature should be based on respect and care. If we treat nature kindly, it will continue to support us. If we destroy it, we harm ourselves too. Nature teaches us lessons of balance, patience, and cooperation.
Living close to the organic world means knowing the land, respecting animals, and living simply. It means walking in forests, watching birds, and understanding how everything is connected.
In today’s busy life, people often forget this connection. But when we return to nature, we feel peace and freedom. We remember that we are not separate from the earth: we belong to it. This understanding helps us live more fully, more kindly, and more wisely.
4. What is the tone of the essay?
The tone of the essay is thoughtful, calm, and wise. Snyder writes with gentle authority and respect for nature. His words are poetic and peaceful, and he speaks in a way that invites the reader to reflect and observe the world more closely. He also sounds hopeful and encourages a humble and caring way of living.
5. What joys can we enjoy as human beings?Snyder says we can enjoy many simple and deep joys as human beings. These include spending time with friends, drinking coffee together, feeling the wind, watching clouds, and being present in the moment. He also says there is joy in learning the land, crossing rivers, and telling good stories when we return. These small, mindful experiences connect us to nature and give us peace, happiness, and freedom.
Discussion
1. Do you really believe you are an animal?
Yes, I believe I am an animal. Like all other animals, I have a body that grows, breathes, feels, and reacts naturally. I depend on food, water, and air to live. My emotions and instincts, like fear, joy, and curiosity, also show that I am a living creature of nature.
2. In what specific ways are human beings animals?Human beings are animals because we have bodies that work on their own, like breathing and heartbeat. We feel fear, love, and hunger just like other animals. We move, sleep, and respond to danger or comfort naturally. Even our language, thinking, and culture developed from our animal instincts over time.
3. What sorts of things do we do that have their basis in our animal nature?
Many of our actions come from our animal nature. We blink, breathe, and jump in fear without thinking. We seek food, warmth, safety, and social connection. Our habits, like protecting family, reacting to sound, and even enjoying play and rest are based on natural animal behaviour.
4. How do you distinguish "domestic" from "wild"?
"Domestic" refers to things that are controlled, tamed, or shaped by humans, like house pets, gardens, or daily routines. "Wild" means free, natural, and not controlled by people, like forests, wild animals, and natural instincts. Wild things live on their own, without human rules.
5. "No expectations, alert and sufficient, grateful and careful, generous and direct" (9). Discuss the philosophical import of this expression.
This expression shares a deep life lesson. It means living in the present without demanding too much. Being alert means staying aware; sufficient means being content with what we have. Grateful and careful show respect for life. Generous and direct means being kind and honest. Together, these ideas teach a way of living in harmony with nature: simple, peaceful, and free. It is a gentle guide for how to live wisely in the world.
0 Comments